Association for the Cooperative Advancement of Science and Education
Home Work Community Publications Contact

Rating Performance on Assessment Activities

ACASE Assessment Activities Building an Assessment Activity Administering Assessment Activities > Rating Performance on Assessment Activities Evaluating Assessment Activities Supporting Student Learning through Assessment Activities Supporting Teaching Practice through Assessment Activities
Grading is not Assessment

Grading and assessment must be clearly distinguished in order to fully realize the potential of formative assessments. We use the term assessment strictly to refer to examining the degree to which learning goals are attained. Grading, on the other hand, is a process of assigning ranks, scores, letter grades, etc. to students (in the English system these are referred to as ‘marks’ (Black, 1998). Typically these scores are the number or percent right on a test (or some scaled equivalent), thus information on the degree to which specific learning goals were attained is lost. The value of grades for motivational purposes is questionable (Stiggins, 2005), as is their educational value (Zachos, Research Bulletin article).

We recommend that teachers use information about student attainment only to guide instructional planning. If grading is required for some administrative purpose, give grades to students based on the degree to which they meet the work specifications given by the teacher (e.g., completing all portions of the assessment form).

The benefits of not grading student attainment on the assessment include:

  • We find out what the student really thinks and believes instead of what he or she thinks will get a high grade from the teacher
  • We protect the student’s relationship with nature and the phenomenon from being corrupted by the grading process.
  • We present an antidote to the presence of fear in the educational setting

Black, Paul and Dylan Wiliam. (1998) Inside the Black Box: Raising Standards Through Classroom Assessment. Phi Delta Kappan Website 80(2)

Stiggins, Richard J. (2005). Student-Involved Assessment for Learning

Zachos, Paul. (2004). Discovering the True Nature of Educational Assessment. Research Bulletin 9(2). The Research Institute for Waldorf Education.

All materials on this website are copyright ACASE. All rights are reserved.
If you wish to use materials found on this site, prior written consent is required. Please contact copyright@acase.org.
Please report any errors on these pages to webmaster@acase.org